Rows of blue agave in the fields of Los Altos in Jalisco, the highland region that supplies much of the tequila industry
One plant family, several denominations, a great deal of nonsense

Mezcal and Tequila

The single most useful sentence about Mexican spirits is this one: tequila is a mezcal. Everything else — the smoke, the worm, the salt and lime, the price of a bottle — makes more sense once that is settled.

Mezcal is a spirit distilled from agave — any agave. It is made from more than thirty agave species, varieties and subvarieties, out of a genus running to almost two hundred. Tequila is the subset made only from blue agave, in a defined region of Jalisco and a few neighbouring areas, and it is by a wide margin the most consumed mezcal in the world.

This guide covers where each actually comes from, why one is smoky and the other is not, the UNESCO agave landscape you can walk into, the Oaxacan palenques that make most of the mezcal, and the other agave drinks — pulque, raicilla, bacanora — plus sotol, which is not agave at all.

The relationshipTequila is a mezcal made only from blue agave
Tequila countryAround Tequila, 65 km north-west of Guadalajara, and Los Altos de Jalisco
Mezcal countryRoughly 90 per cent of Mexican mezcal comes from Oaxaca
UNESCOAgave Landscape of Tequila, inscribed 2006, 35,019 hectares
Trimmed agave hearts, the piñas, stacked at a distillery in the town of Tequila
Chapter 01

One plant, one method, several legal names

Agave · Piña · Denominations of origin

Almost every Mexican spirit in this guide is the same idea executed in different places under different rules: cook the heart of an agave, ferment it, distil it.

What is actually distilled

The agave is not a cactus. It is a succulent of the genus Agave, in the same family as asparagus, and the part that matters is the heart — the piña, so called because a trimmed one looks like an enormous pineapple. The plant stores years of sugar in it, which is why an agave is harvested once, at maturity, and then is gone.

Fermented agave drinks existed here long before the Spanish arrived; pulque is the surviving one. Distillation turned that tradition into the spirits on the shelf.

The names are geography, not recipes

Mezcal is the general term. Tequila is mezcal from blue agave, made in its region. Raicilla, bacanora and sotol are separate denominations of origin covering separate places — and sotol is not even made from agave.

So when a bar offers you "mezcal or tequila", the honest translation is: smoky pit-roasted agave from the south, or steamed blue agave from the west. Both are mezcal in the wider sense.

The traditional masonry oven in which agave hearts are baked at a tequila distillery in Jalisco
Chapter 02

Why one is smoky and the other is not

Pit versus oven · Tahona · The still

The difference in the glass is decided at the cooking stage, before a drop of anything has been distilled.

Roasted or steamed

Traditional mezcal cooks the piñas in a pit oven: a hole lined with hot stones, filled with agave, covered over with fibre and earth and left for days. Wood smoke gets into the sugars and stays there through fermentation and distillation. That is the smoke.

Most tequila is cooked with steam, in masonry ovens or in autoclaves, and picks up no smoke at all. Smoke is a production signature, not a quality mark — and a mezcal that tastes of nothing but smoke is usually a thin spirit with something to hide.

Crushing, fermenting, distilling

The cooked agave is crushed — by machine, by a stone tahona turned by a horse, or by hand with mallets — then fermented in wooden vats or animal skins, often on wild yeast, and distilled, frequently twice, in copper or clay.

Every one of those choices is tasteable, which is why two mezcals from villages ten kilometres apart can be entirely different drinks made from the same plant.

Copper stills in a tequila distillery in the town of Tequila, Jalisco
Chapter 03

Tequila: Jalisco, red soil, and a World Heritage landscape

65 km from Guadalajara · 300 million plants a year · UNESCO 2006

An industry large enough to be visible from the air, in a landscape that has been listed precisely because it is an industry.

The region

Tequila is made from blue agave grown chiefly around the town of Tequila, about 65 kilometres north-west of Guadalajara, and in Los Altos de Jalisco. The red volcanic soil suits the plant and more than 300 million agaves are harvested there each year.

Where they grow shows up in the glass: highland agaves are larger and sweeter in aroma, valley agaves more herbaceous. That is a real distinction and a good distillery will happily talk about it.

The listed landscape

The Agave Landscape and Ancient Industrial Facilities of Tequila became a cultural World Heritage Site in 2006. It covers 35,019 hectares of working agave fields together with the towns of Tequila, Magdalena, El Arenal and Amatitán and the distilleries in them.

The listing is explicit that agave has been used here since the sixteenth century for the spirit and for at least two millennia for fermented drinks and for cloth. Visiting is easy — there are organised tours and a tourist train from Guadalajara — and it is a genuinely handsome piece of country.

Mezcal being produced in Oaxaca, the state that accounts for the great majority of Mexican mezcal
Chapter 04

Mezcal: Oaxaca, and the palenque

c. 90% from Oaxaca · Santiago Matatlán · Small producers

The interesting end of Mexican spirits is agricultural, unpolished and usually run by a family. It is also half an hour from the centre of Oaxaca.

Where it comes from

Mezcal may legally be made in a number of states, but roughly nine tenths of Mexico's mezcal comes from Oaxaca. The producing villages of the Central Valleys are a short drive from the city, and Santiago Matatlán bills itself as the world capital of the stuff.

A palenque is the workshop: pit oven, tahona, wooden vats, a couple of stills, dogs, and a great deal of agave in various states. There is nothing corporate about it and that is the point.

Varieties, and what to ask

Espadín is the workhorse agave and makes most of the mezcal you will meet. Beyond it are the wild and semi-wild varieties — tobalá, tepeztate, madrecuixe and others — which take many more years to mature, cost accordingly, and taste like their own thing.

Ask which agave, how old the plant was, where it was roasted and whether the water was added or the spirit came off the still at that strength. A producer will answer all four without pausing.

Bottled mezcal lined up at a producer in Teotitlán del Valle, Oaxaca
Chapter 05

Pulque, raicilla, bacanora — and sotol, which is not agave

Fermented, not distilled · Four more denominations

Once you leave the two famous names the map gets more interesting, and one of the drinks on it is made from a completely different plant.

Pulque, the one that is not a spirit

Pulque is the fermented sap of the maguey — not distilled at all. It is milky, viscous and sour, it has been made in central Mexico for millennia, and before the conquest it was sacred and restricted to particular classes of people. It became secular afterwards, peaked commercially in the late nineteenth century, and was then largely pushed aside by beer.

It survives, it is having a revival in Mexico City pulquerías, and it is worth trying once whatever you conclude about the texture.

The regional distillates

Raicilla comes from south-western Jalisco, has about three hundred years of history and its own denomination of origin. Bacanora is a Sonoran agave spirit whose distillation was outright illegal until 1992, despite generations of bootlegging, and which has had a denomination since 2000.

Sotol is the outlier: it is distilled from Dasylirion, a plant of the Chihuahuan desert and not an agave at all, and has been a denomination since 2002 covering Chihuahua, Coahuila and Durango. It sits on the same shelf and is not the same thing.

A small mezcal shop in Santa María del Tule, Oaxaca
Chapter 06

Buying and drinking without being sold a story

100% agave · No worm · Sipped, not shot

Three habits separate people who enjoy this from people who have a bad night and a firm opinion afterwards.

Read the label

With tequila, look for 100% agave. Anything without it is a mixto, legally permitted to be part cane sugar, and it is where most of the world's bad tequila experiences come from. The age categories — blanco, reposado, añejo — describe barrel time, not quality; a good blanco beats a mediocre añejo.

With mezcal, the interesting bottles name the agave, the village and the maker. A bottle that names none of those and leans on a worm is selling a souvenir.

Drink it the way it is drunk here

Mezcal is taken straight, slowly, at room temperature, in a small wide cup, often with orange and sal de gusano alongside. It is not shot. Salt and lime is a tequila ritual and largely an export one, and it exists mainly to cover mixto.

If you are tasting at palenques, hire a driver. Tasting is the entire point of the day, the road back through the valleys is not straight, and Mexican drink-driving enforcement is not a formality.

The family, sorted out

Six drinks, and what actually separates them

All of these except sotol are made from agave. Denominations of origin are legal regions, not quality grades.

DrinkMade fromWhereDistilled?What marks it
MezcalMore than 30 agave species and varietiesSeveral states; c. 90% OaxacaYesPit-roasted, so usually smoky
TequilaBlue agave onlyJalisco and defined neighbouring areasYesSteam-cooked; look for 100% agave
RaicillaAgaveSouth-western JaliscoYesOwn denomination; c. 300 years old
BacanoraAgaveSonoraYesIllegal until 1992; denomination since 2000
SotolDasylirion — not agaveChihuahua, Coahuila, DurangoYesDenomination since 2002; a different plant
PulqueMaguey sapCentral MexicoNo — fermentedMilky, viscous, sour; pre-Hispanic

The worm is not a tradition, it is a marketing device. A larva in the bottle tells you about the bottler, not the spirit, and no producer whose mezcal you would want to drink puts one in. Sal de gusano — ground larva, salt and chilli, served on the side with orange — is a different thing entirely and is genuinely local.

Smoke is a method, not a mark of quality. It comes from roasting the agave in a pit. Judge a mezcal on what is underneath the smoke, and be suspicious of one where nothing is.

What goes wrong

Six ways to have a bad time with agave

Four are in the buying and two are in the drinking.

Buying mixto tequila

If the label does not say 100% agave, part of what is in the bottle is cane sugar. This is the single largest cause of people believing they dislike tequila.

Shooting mezcal

It is a sipping spirit, taken at room temperature over a long time. Throwing it back wastes an expensive glass and teaches you nothing about it.

Buying the bottle with the worm

A souvenir dressed as a tradition. The good bottles name the agave, the village and the maker instead.

Driving between palenques

Tasting is the point of the day. Hire a driver or join a tour; the valleys are winding and enforcement is real.

Judging by smokiness

Smoke comes from the pit, not from quality. Some of the best mezcal is barely smoky, and some of the smokiest has nothing else in it.

Assuming añejo means better

The categories describe time in barrel. Oak can improve a spirit and can also bury it. Taste the blanco first.

Before you go

Six things to settle first

Which region, how you will get around it, and what you intend to bring home.

Tequila or mezcal country

Jalisco for the World Heritage landscape and an organised industry; Oaxaca for small producers and the better stories. They are far apart.

A driver

Non-negotiable for a tasting day. Build it into the cost of the outing rather than treating it as an extra.

Eat first

Palenque visits start earlier and run longer than people expect, and the tasting is generous. Do not arrive on an empty stomach.

Luggage allowance

Spirits go in the hold, and glass needs padding. Decide how many bottles before you start buying them.

Ask four questions

Which agave, how old, roasted where, and what strength off the still. The answers tell you whether you are in a workshop or a shop.

Try pulque once

It is nothing like the others and it is the oldest thing on the list. Mexico City is the easiest place to do it properly.

Honest planning

Frequently asked questions

Answers written to make the plan realistic rather than optimistic.

Tequila is a kind of mezcal. Mezcal is a spirit distilled from any agave — it is made from more than thirty agave species, varieties and subvarieties, out of a genus with almost two hundred — while tequila is made only from blue agave and only in its defined region. The most widely consumed mezcal in the world is, in fact, tequila. The reason they taste so different is mostly the cooking: industrial tequila steams the agave, and traditional mezcal roasts it in a pit, which is where the smoke comes from.
From the blue agave country around the town of Tequila, about 65 kilometres north-west of Guadalajara, and from the Jaliscan highlands, Los Altos de Jalisco. The red volcanic soil there suits the plant, and more than 300 million agaves are harvested in the region each year. The growing area matters to the flavour: highland agaves tend to be larger and sweeter in aroma, valley agaves more herbaceous.
Yes. The Agave Landscape and Ancient Industrial Facilities of Tequila was inscribed as a cultural World Heritage Site in 2006. It covers 35,019 hectares of living, working agave fields plus the towns of Tequila, Magdalena, El Arenal and Amatitán and their distilleries. The listing is explicit that agave has been used here since the sixteenth century for the spirit and for at least two thousand years for fermented drinks and for cloth.
Because of how the agave heart is cooked before fermentation. Traditional mezcal is roasted in a pit oven lined with hot stones and covered over, and that wood smoke goes into the sugar and through the still. Most tequila is cooked in masonry ovens or autoclaves with steam, which leaves no smoke. Smoke is therefore a production signature, not a quality mark, and a mezcal that is only smoke is usually hiding a thin spirit behind it.
Legally in a number of states, but in practice some 90 per cent of Mexican mezcal comes from Oaxaca. The producing villages in the Oaxacan valleys — Santiago Matatlán calls itself the world capital of it — are within an easy drive of the city, and visiting a palenque is one of the better half-days in Mexico. Small producers are the interesting end of the market and the one worth your money.
Pulque is not distilled at all: it is the fermented sap of the maguey, milky, viscous and sour, made in central Mexico for millennia, sacred before the conquest, at its commercial peak in the late nineteenth century and then largely displaced by beer. Raicilla is a distilled agave spirit from south-western Jalisco with about three centuries of history and its own denomination of origin. Bacanora is a Sonoran agave spirit that was outright illegal until 1992 and has had a denomination since 2000. Sotol is the odd one out: it is made from Dasylirion, a different plant entirely, in Chihuahua, Coahuila and Durango, with a denomination since 2002.
In Mexico, mezcal is generally drunk straight and slowly, at room temperature, in a small wide cup, often with orange and sal de gusano on the side. It is not shot, and it is not salt-and-lime — that is a tequila ritual and mostly an export one. With tequila, ask for something labelled 100% agave; anything else is a mixto, legally allowed to be part cane sugar, and it is where most bad hangovers and bad opinions come from.
Yes, and they are two different trips. The Tequila landscape near Guadalajara is a World Heritage site with working distilleries, a tourist train and a well-organised industry, and it is easy. The Oaxacan palenques are small, agricultural and unpolished, and you will usually meet the person who made what you are tasting. If you only do one, do the palenques — and go with a driver, because tasting is the entire point and the road back is not straight.
Continue the story

Look for 100% agave, sip it, and hire the driver

Those three things cover most of what separates a good agave day from a bad one. Ask which plant, which village and which maker, and let the answers rather than the smoke decide what you buy.

Advertisement