Route A, and why it is the default
Twenty-four nights, into Cancún and out of Mexico City: three in Tulum, two in Valladolid, four in Mérida, two in Campeche, five in Oaxaca, four in San Cristóbal, four in the capital. Inside the peninsula the Tren Maya does the work — a 1,554-kilometre line whose Campeche to Cancún section opened on 15 December 2023, with Mérida to Cancún published at around three and a half hours.
Two flights only: Campeche or Mérida to Oaxaca, and Tuxtla to Mexico City. One overnight coach, Oaxaca to San Cristóbal. It gives up Baja, the Pacific and the whole colonial Bajío. Remember that the train's Mérida station is Teya, outside the city, and add the transfer.
Routes B and C, for people who have been before
Route B, twenty-one nights, no coast at all: six in Mexico City with a day at Teotihuacán, two in Puebla, two in Querétaro, three in Guanajuato, three in Morelia, then the night coach south for five in Oaxaca. One flight, out of Oaxaca. It is the cheapest route to run and the most concentrated, and it gives up the sea entirely.
Route C, twenty-two nights, water first: five in La Paz with the islands, two in Cabo San Lucas, fly to four in Mexico City, fly to three on Isla Mujeres and four in Tulum. Three flights, no long coach legs, and it gives up Oaxaca, Chiapas and every colonial city in the country. It is the route for a second trip, not a first.